Choosing Fish For Your Saltwater Aquarium
Choosing fish for your aquarium is one of the most exciting parts of the saltwater hobby, but it’s also where many beginners make mistakes. The right stocking plan will keep your reef peaceful, colorful, and healthy for years. The wrong mix can lead to aggression, disease, and constant frustration.
Before you buy anything, make sure your tank is fully cycled and stable. If you’re not sure, review our guide on cycling a saltwater aquarium so your new fish have a safe home from day one.
Start With Tank Size, Then Temperament
Your tank size should be the first filter for any fish you consider. Many beautiful species simply grow too large or are too active for smaller aquariums.
Match Fish To Your Aquarium Size
- Nano tanks (10–30 gallons): Ideal for clownfish, gobies, firefish, and small blennies.
- Medium tanks (40–75 gallons): Can handle a small tang, dwarf angels, and peaceful wrasses.
- Large tanks (90+ gallons): Open the door to larger tangs, multiple wrasses, and more complex communities.
Always use the adult size of the fish, not the juvenile size at the store, when deciding if it fits your aquarium.
Temperament And Compatibility
Once you know what your tank can physically support, focus on behavior. A peaceful community is far more enjoyable than a tank full of bullies.
- Peaceful fish: Clownfish, chromis, gobies, firefish, and many blennies.
- Semi-aggressive: Dwarf angelfish, some wrasses, and dottybacks.
- Aggressive: Triggers, large angels, and some damsels.
As a rule, avoid mixing multiple territorial species that occupy the same space (for example, several sand-sifting gobies in a small tank). For more ideas, check our beginner saltwater fish list to see proven, compatible starter species.
Reef-Safe Choices And Stocking Order
If you keep corals or plan to in the future, focus on reef-safe fish. Many species nip at fleshy corals or invertebrates like shrimp and clams.
Reef-Safe vs. Not-So-Safe
- Generally reef-safe: Clownfish, most gobies, many wrasses (research each species), chromis, cardinalfish.
- Use caution: Dwarf angelfish (may nip), some wrasses that eat shrimp, larger hawkfish.
- Usually not reef-safe: Butterflyfish, many triggers, large angels, some puffers.
When in doubt, look up multiple sources for a species and search for long-term hobbyist experiences before buying.
Smart Stocking Order
Even compatible fish can clash if added in the wrong order. A good rule is to add the most peaceful and timid fish first, then semi-aggressive, and finally any dominant species.
Tip: Quarantine new fish whenever possible. A simple quarantine tank dramatically reduces the risk of introducing marine ich or other parasites to your display.
Take your time—add a fish, let the system adjust, and monitor behavior and water quality before adding the next one. If you’re planning a full reef, it can help to sketch a stocking plan alongside your beginner reef tank setup so fish, rockwork, and corals all work together.
Final Thoughts
Thoughtful fish selection is the foundation of a successful saltwater aquarium. Start with your tank size, research each species’ adult size and temperament, confirm reef safety, and introduce fish slowly in a planned order. With patience and planning, you’ll build a vibrant, peaceful community that’s a joy to watch and easy to maintain.
Sources
- Fenner, R. M. The Conscientious Marine Aquarist. Microcosm Ltd.
- Michael, S. Marine Fishes: 500+ Essential-To-Know Aquarium Species. T.F.H. Publications.
- Sprung, J., & Delbeek, J. C. The Reef Aquarium series. Ricordea Publishing.
By
